Three more French roses
I was in NYC for a few days and I walked into as many wine stores as I could and in one of them, I found three more French roses that made me hopeful. Sadly, they were all disappointments, essentially.
This continues to prove the point – there are not many good roses from 2016, at least so far – no matter how many I taste. Well, this is the 5th attempt to taste roses in a group, and these were some of the worst.
The previous tasting – had my roundup of best kosher roses and nothing has changed after this tasting – sadly.
I tasted three wines from Provence, two from the Cotes du Provence and one from Bandol. Shockingly, the mevushal Almae rose was the best of the tasting. I tried to look up the Almae Rose, and all I find was the Alma rose from Dalton, which we had at the first rose tasting.
I have no idea who this Almae rose is – it is made by Rashbi wines, but not sure of more than that. The other two are famous – and neither has been very good for me, on previous tastings, and this one was no different for me either. The 2016 Bandol Rose and 2016 100 Tropez Rose. The funny part is that when I put some of the Almae rose into the Bandol it was very nice, it became a really nice Provence. When I did it the other way around (Bandol into the Almae) it was not very interesting at all. Adding anything to the Tropez netted us nothing.
The notes follow below:
2016 Almae Rose, Cotes de Provence – Score: B+ to A-
This wine is a blend of 60% Grenache, 20% Cinsault, and 20% Syrah. The nose on this wine is nice with peach, rose hips, floral notes, slate, and good apricot. The mouth on this medium bodied wine is nice, with good weight, showing nice acid, good structure, with nice fruit pith, strawberry and creme, nice light tannin, and nectarines. The wine is slightly sweet but very nice and round.
2016 100 Tropez Rose, Cotes de Provence – Score: B to B+
The nose on this wine is lovely with good citrus, grapefruit, lemon, raspberry, and peach. The mouth on this medium weight wine is flat, lacking the middle, showing fun saline, and green olives, with strawberry, Sad.
2016 Domaine Bunan, Bandol, Provence – Score: B+
A really nice nose of strawberry and creme, vanilla, rose hips, with juicy raspberry, and good spice. The mouth on the medium bodied wine is ok, but lacking the acid I crave, it has an ok balance, with more fruit pith than acid, that does help it a lot, not bitter, with good sweet red fruit, showing a bit of sweetness, but balanced with slate. A nice enough wine, wish it had more acid and more interesting notes.
Posted on August 17, 2017, in Kosher Rose Wine, Uncategorized, Wine, Wine Tasting and tagged 100 Tropez, Almae, Bandol, Cotes de Provence, Domaine Buman, Rose. Bookmark the permalink. 4 Comments.
That is disappointing! How come! Could there be a problem with shipping from France and/or storage in NYC?
I published a list of popular French roses recently, broadly appreciated (although not the super-highest (and expensive) quality either) http://socialvignerons.com/2017/07/25/10-top-french-rose-wines/
Have you tried any of these?
Curious to hear what you expect out of a good rose, and how it was missing from these.
Cheers, and thanks for sharing 🙂
If you read my previous posts on rose this year – I look for balance with a good acid core. Of that three none had that. The Almae was close – but not one I would buy again either.
Thats sad… i tried the tropez not mevushal and it was really fruity and definitely provence style, it seems like the one you tried is the mevushal one
Pingback: Top kosher White and Sparkling wines that I have tasted in 2017 | Wine Musings Blog